Switch to हिंदी

Health, Fitness, Beauty & Diet | Pregnancy & Parenting | Diseases & Home Remedies | TheHealthSite.com

Health, Fitness, Beauty & Diet | Pregnancy & Parenting | Diseases & Home Remedies | TheHealthSite.com

हिंदी
  • Health A-Z
  • Home Remedies
  • Diseases
    • Type 1 Diabetes
    • Type 2 Diabetes
    • Cancer
    • Heart Attack
    • Pneumonia
    • Diseases A-Z
  • Diet & Fitness
    • Weight Management
    • Exercise & Body Building
    • Diet & Recipes
    • Yoga
  • Coronavirus
  • News
  • Pregnancy
    • Conceiving
    • Infertility
    • Labour & Delivery
    • Pregnancy week-by-week
    • Breastfeeding
    • Baby Names
  • Beauty
    • Skin
    • Hair
    • Grooming
  • Photos
  • Videos
BLA21 cibil.com ageas federal zee hindustan
Home / Health News / Commercial surrogacy: experts debate over Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016

Commercial surrogacy: experts debate over Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016

Many from the industry call it a regressive and insensitive move while some welcome it, saying a complete ban is better than mere regulation.

By: Agencies   | | Published: April 4, 2018 3:01 pm
Tags: In vitro fertilisation  IVF  IVF treatment  Surrogacy  
Surrogacy in India

With the Union Cabinet clearing the decks for banning commercial surrogacy, many from the industry call it a regressive and insensitive move while some welcome it, saying a complete ban is better than mere regulation. The Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2016, was cleared by the Union Cabinet last month. It prohibits commercial surrogacy in India with the only exception for Indian infertile couples married for five years, provided they bring a close relative to be the surrogate mother strictly on an altruistic basis. Also Read - Egg freezing on rise in India: Is it the best choice to make? Know the pros and cons

The bill also proposes to regulate surrogacy by establishing a National Surrogacy Board at the central level and simlar authorities in states and Union territories. Also Read - Mild IVF: A safer option for 37+ older women or who have low ovarian reserve



Surrogacy involves renting a womb and getting pregnant through assisted reproduction technology in which neither of the gametes (egg or sperm) belongs to the woman or her husband. In India, nearly 10,000 surrogacy cycles are done annually and the proposed bill is likely to narrow options for those wanting children. It also shuts out an income-generating opportunity for women who act as surrogate mothers. Also Read - Can you get pregnant if you suffer from endometriosis?

There have been incidents of unethical practices, exploitation of surrogate mothers, abandonment of children born and rackets of intermediaries importing human embryos and gametes.

Bijayalaxmi Nanda, who teaches political science and gender in Delhi University’s Miranda House, said the issue was very complex and, as a concept, there was no problem with commercial surrogacy, if regulated strictly.

“It’s just another kind of bodily work like kidney, blood donation. However, the rules are heavily inclined towards the rich clients and lead to exploitation of the poor surrogate.”

Nanda, the author of “Sex-Selective Abortion and the State”, told IANS that commercial surrogacy was okay if equality between the clients and the surrogate mothers is guaranteed, ensuring fair conditions and taking care of the short- and long-term health hazards of the surrogates.

But the problem in India is that “the marginalised have no voice even if there are laws to protect their interests”.

Nanda said gender equality was also an issue.

“In fact, adoption should be the first choice, overcoming the desire for a child with genetic relationship. This again promotes the patriarchal mindset in society, which the government with surrogacy gives its stamp of approval.”

But Rita Bakshi, who runs a fertility centre in Delhi, felt that the amendments to the surrogacy bill were “retrograde and orthodox… completely neglecting and overlooking single parents and married people who suffer from medical problems”.

She said the government had “disregarded physically unfit people with severe and chronic illnesses like thalassemia, anemia, tuberculosis” that make unborn babies prone to these diseases.

Sweta Gupta, a senior consultant on fertility solutions, said gestational surrogacy was supported in India where pregnancy results from the transfer of an embryo created by IVF, in a manner so that the resulting child is genetically unrelated to the surrogate but related to intended parents.

Archana Bajaj Dhawan, Gynaecologist and IVF Expert, said the proposed legislation “is expected to ensure effective regulation of surrogacy.

“But prohibiting commercial surrogacy will not be wise as identifying altruistic surrogacy for the needy couples would indeed prove a tough task. Sometimes even close relatives do not come forward as surrogates.”

Advocating strong regulation to check unethical practices, she said the “regressive move” of prohibition would restrict the scope and benefits of surrogacy.

Among the most vocal opponents of commercial surrogacy is author, journalist and human rights activist Pinki Virani, whose “Politics of the Womb” details how a section of the medical lobby was involved in making men feel ashamed of their infertility equating it with their virility.

“As a consequence, the largest exploitation that is happening in its name is that of human eggs,” she said, adding women produce only one viable egg a month but they are being injected with hormones.

“Girls are being harvested 40 eggs, 50 eggs, and these eggs are being removed and we have no idea where they are going. They are not all going towards baby-making. So, there is egg trafficking.

“There is human trafficking in the form of commercial surrogates, who are also being injected over and over and over again… Is that what anybody in this world wants? Because this is what is being done to women and young girls the world over in the name of an innocent unborn,” said Virani.

Source: IANS
Image source: Shutterstock

Published : April 4, 2018 3:01 pm
Read Disclaimer

Book Review: If Our Bodies Could Talk - Operating and Maintaining a Human Body

Book Review: If Our Bodies Could Talk - Operating and Maintaining a Human Body

Whooping cough resurging in US

Whooping cough resurging in US

Please Wait. Article Loading ....

Coronavirus Updates

Coronavirus Updates

Stay Informed, Be Safe

  • It is ‘unrealistic’ that COVID-19 pandemic would be over by 2021 end: WHO expert
  • COVID-19 vaccine for variants: Pfizer, Moderna test a third ‘booster’ dose for efficacy
  • Man dies minutes after receiving second dose of COVID-19 vaccine in Maharashtra's Bhiwandi district
  • 'All private hospitals can give COVID-19 vaccines only if....': Center releases guidelines
  • Vaccine acceptance: Women in India more willing to get COVID-19 shot than those in the US

Health Calculators

BMI Calculator
bmi Calculator
Ideal Body Weight
ideal body weight
Daily Calorie Intake
Daily calorie intake
Calories Burned
calories burned

Related Stories

Egg freezing on rise in India: Is it the best choice to make? Know the pros and cons

Egg freezing on rise in India: Is it the best choice to make? Know the pros and cons

Mild IVF: A safer option for 37+ older women or who have low ovarian reserve

Mild IVF: A safer option for 37+ older women or who have low ovarian reserve

Can you get pregnant if you suffer from endometriosis?

Can you get pregnant if you suffer from endometriosis?

Expert Speak: Busting 8 common myths about IVF

Expert Speak: Busting 8 common myths about IVF

IVF raises cancer risk in children: Study

IVF raises cancer risk in children: Study

Health News in Hindi

डायबिटीज के साथ भी स्‍वस्‍थ जीवन जीना है आसान, सिर्फ एक्‍सपर्ट की इन बातों का रखें ध्‍यान

Fittest Couple in Bollywood: पूजा बत्रा और नवाब शाह का फिटनेस मंत्र योग और बॉडी बिल्डिंग

President Kovind receives Covid-19 vaccine: राष्‍ट्रपति रामनाथ कोविंद ने लगाई कोरोना वैक्‍सीन, दिल्‍ली में लगा पहला टीका

Lemon Peel Benefits: नींबू के रस से ज्‍यादा फायदेमंद होते हैं नींबू के छिलके, जानिए इसके हैरान कर देने वाले फायदे

Aarogya Setu App for corona vaccine: आरोग्‍य सेतु एप से करें कोरोना वैक्‍सीन के लिए रजिस्‍ट्रेशन, ये हैं 5 आसान स्‍टेप्‍स

Read All

Recent Posts

  • President Ram Nath Kovind gets first dose of COVID-19 vaccine at Delhi’s RR hospital
  • Can Cochlear implant make a deaf child hear? Let’s hear it from the recipients
  • TV actor Kishwer Merchant announces pregnancy at 40; know the complications of late pregnancy
  • Mobile use can make your kid less creative and more analytical
  • Hearing screening for newborns should be made compulsory in India: Experts

About The health Site

TheHealthSite.com is India's largest health site with more than 40 lakh unique visitors per month. We focus on fitness, beauty, health, pregnancy and more.

Most popular health and wellness website in India in 2012 at the Website of the year awards.

health@corp.india.com
+91 – 22 – 6697 1234
Landline Phone number 91 – 22 – 2490 0302.

ZEE ENTERTAINMENT ENTERPRISES LTD, 18th floor, A-Wing, Marathon Futurex, N. M. Joshi Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra 400013.

Useful Links

  • Weight Loss
  • Keto Diet Tips
  • Skin Care Tips
  • Intermittent Fasting
  • Apple Cider Vinegar
  • Ashwagandha
  • Cancer
  • Pneumonia
  • Diarrhoea
  • Dengue
  • Typhoid
  • Tuberculosis
  • Chickenpox
  • Chikungunya
  • Depression
  • Hepatitis
  • Diabetes
  • Type 2 diabetes
  • Arthritis
  • Swine Flu
  • Baby Names
  • Cough and cold
  • Heart Attack
  • Breast Cancer
  • Ebola Virus
  • Dengue
  • Malaria
  • International Yoga Day
  • Hypotension
  • Heart Failure
  • Asthma
  • Brain Tumour
  • Celebrity Fitness
  • Goitre
  • HIV/AIDS

We respect your privacy

  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Author Profiles

Copyright © 2021 Zee Entertainment Enterprises Limited. All rights reserved.